A week ago my father took his final breath. He went quickly and peacefully after dinner. He’d had such a good day, eating all his food and even joking with his carers, that they did not have any inkling they were seeing a man in his final hours. I’m glad it happened that way.
If I could have spoken to my father, this is what I would have said.
I’m sorry, Dad, that I’m not by your side right now. I know you would have preferred to die in the house you had lived in for twenty five years. I’m really sorry I could not make that happen – you never got to see your house again.
But you were in a happy place. You didn’t like it initially, of course – who does? At Thanksgiving, when they asked you what you were thankful for, you said, ‘I’m thankful to be in this happy place.’
It was indeed a happy place, this small care home in a leafy suburb where they treated you as a person, not a number. Everyone knew your name and you knew theirs. They really looked after you. They are now shattered that you left without warning.
You were not a man of many words. We learned more about your life from files you had kept – which we found while cleaning up – than from anything you ever told us. You never talked about your achievements, almost as if you were a little embarrassed that they were not enough, that what you had done did not stack up in some people’s eyes. For a boy from a small town, born when Malaysia was still Malaya, who died 10,182 miles from his place of birth, you went a long way. You have a lot to be proud of.
Your own traditional Chinese father and mother did not speak English. You told me how, on your first day at an English-language school in Teluk Intan (Telok Anson in your days), you had no idea what the class teacher was saying. When he asked the whole class to stand up, your bum remained firmly on your seat. Fortunately, the teacher guessed that you did not understand. He was a Malay man who had married a Chinese woman and, having learned Cantonese himself, he said to you, ‘Hei sun, hei sun!’ (Get up, get up!).
From him you learned your first English words. And you never looked back. You were taught grammar the old-fashioned way. You had to learn spelling and syntax and punctuation; you knew the purpose of an apostrophe; you did not, unlike so many today, confuse ‘it’s’ with ‘its’.
But you were also a man of your generation and culture. Although you were interested in science, you never discussed science with me. When I announced my desire to become a physicist, you told me to ‘forget my fanciful dreams’. In those days, I suspect you could only imagine boys becoming physicists. Thank goodness that I inherited more than your logical mind – I also inherited your obstinacy. I ignored you. In the end I hope I made you proud.
Watching your physical deterioration this past year has been painful. There was no getting away from the reality that you no longer enjoyed the quality of life you’d previously had. You knew the end was near. You also knew the President’s name and what day of the week it was. I take comfort from the fact that you still smiled.
On your last full night on Earth, I’m told you sang through the night, keeping the entire house awake. In the morning you seemed oblivious to having been up. You continued bossing your carers about, demanding coffee.
I smile at this story. That extraordinary burst of energy would have worn anyone out.
Please, take it easy now, Dad. There is nothing more you need worry about, no one you must provide for. Sleep well.

Dear Selina,
This is a beautiful tribute to your father. I was moved by how, in such a brief piece, you gave a vivid sense of who your father was and how much he meant to you.
I hope you are doing well and send you warm regards,
Elaine
Dear Elaine,
Thank you for reaching out. Loss isn’t easy, but I hope writing will once again come to my rescue.
Very best wishes,
Selina
so sad to see our parents leaving us. my condolences! I am glad your dad was in a good place – well done to you for perseverance to find the right place for him!
Eddy Chin
14th January, 2025
Dear Selina,
You may grant me my little salute to your dad as I knew him from before you were born.
He was Choo Wah to me, who met my sister in the course of their commercial studies at Anderson School in our home town Ipoh.
He helped her contact her (also my!) biological mother in Telok Anson, unbeknownst to others. Even then, I was happy for my sister, who would be your mom later.
Your dad was a hero, quiet and unsung. He needn’t wear a mask.
He probably sensed he must help my sister, perhaps at her behest. So good of her. So great of him.
Your dad was to me a deciding if not the decisive feature in supporting my sister Fee Lan’s (Lana as she came to be known, as you read on…) fond wish to go to America and settle there. He held her hand in going with her, lock stock and barrel, the both encouraged by first her, then their American guardian, who welcomed them to Uncle Sam’s.
I also feel deeply your dad — the practical man — was instrumental in doing the practicable, when I heard they had initially landed in Los Angeles in time for the Olympic Games, and saw their American experience really begin when they settled in Orlando, Fla. Uncle Choo Wah must have seen Orlando’s safe location against hurricanes and tornadoes. (His stint working on the West Coast post-graduating from some business studies there could have persuaded him to cast his eyes east of California.)
Your dad’s regard and love for your mom was seldom voiced, on the short occasion I visited them. But here’s where he did himself proud : he invited me to join him on a car ride to Tampa. Not after the initial miles did he tell me he was going to take his oath on being granted American citizenship (or as some sort of probationer!). Boy, I witnessed the ceremony which included some twenty other emigrants.
Just one last kudo to your dad. Flashbacking to my days as a track and field aspirant, he was the one who told me I could do with some weightlifting, and the props were at his sister’s house in town (Silibin Road, near Anglo-Chinese School, where I was a student).I went there almost each afternoon prior to running and jumping at the A.C.S. grounds. No one can change my firm belief that those weights helped me realize my dream in the longjump at the A.C.S. and elsewhere. Your dad must share this part of my ‘legacy’. I thank him deeply.
To such a giving brother-in-law, kindly may I say not only goodbye but ‘See you again’ !