An Unexpected Discovery

A few days ago, when I told a Frenchman that I came from Malaysia, he said, ‘Ah, you have a simple language.’ It was not the first time someone had told me that s/he thought Malay “simple”. The sub-text, albeit unarticulated, was usually: “simple language, simple people”.

I felt it again with this Frenchman, a European condescension towards my Asian culture. I thought to myself: what does he even know about Malay?

Malay was a language of my childhood, one of three. My family spoke English and Cantonese at home but I was taught in Malay at school – part of the first intake of students to be educated exclusively in the Malay language in what had previously been English-medium schools.

I learned the language, but failed to appreciate its poetic beauty. This was partly because in Malaysia, Mathematics and the Sciences are more highly regarded than the Humanities, and partly because of the political context in which the switch from English to Malay took place.

It occurred in the aftermath of May 13 1969,  a day on which Malaysians of Chinese origin were targeted for slaughter at the hands of mobs of Malays in Kuala Lumpur’s streets. The killings occurred after UMNO – the political party which has ruled Malaysia since its independence from Britain in 1957 – and its allies lost the popular vote and many parliamentary seats in a general election.

The period afterwards was a time of radical change. Within about a year, Malaysia had a new Prime Minister; within two years, a raft of racially discriminatory measures was put in place. It was then that Malay was imposed as the medium of instruction in previously English-medium schools.

Language, of course, is not only a means of communication: it is also a political tool. In Malaysia certainly, language and religion are used adroitly by UMNO. UMNO understood early on the power of language. It has been uncommonly adept at choosing emotive words and at using these words to craft an insidious political narrative.

Thus I grew up hearing that I was pendatang yang tumpang sahaja di Malaysia, a newcomer who was only squatting in Malaysia. This was the backdrop in which I was taught Malay. Perhaps unsurprisingly, I never stopped to think about what a beautiful language Malay actually is. If French (which I speak) is romantic, then Malay is poetic. It was only when I started writing a novel and began filling my landscapes with characters who ran around speaking different languages that I was struck by just how poetic the Malay language is.

Take for instance the simple concept of homeland. The Malay equivalent is tanahair, literally translated as “soil (tanah) water (air)”, in other words the earth and water from which you come. I hope you will agree that the expression “my soil and water” is much more evocative than “homeland”.

Or take that well-known beast, the “orang-utan”. In truth, the latter is a bastardisation of the words orang, meaning a person, and hutan, meaning forest. Orang hutan is actually “a person of the forest”. The phrase, if you think about it, is immensely inclusive; it says, “Here is the forest, we share it with this creature which is not so different from us – a person of the forest.” For me, orang hutan captures the essence of traditional Malay culture, which was at once utterly respectful of others and very gentle towards them.

Even that wonderful political creation, the bumiputera – the prince (putera) of the earth (bumi) or son of the soil, a person who by dint of race or religion is privileged in Malaysia – has a certain ring to it. From a purely linguistic standpoint, the word bumiputera is really rather beautiful.

There are many other examples, and yet poetic beauty is not what people think of when they mention the Malay language. Instead they say what the Frenchman said to me: Malay is “simple”.

What he and others don’t seem to realise is that Malay was written using the Arabic script, a form known as Jawi, until quite recently. I discovered this for myself while carrying out research for my second novel (for which incidentally I have completed a first draft). Most of this research took place at the National Library of Singapore (whose generous opening hours of between 10 a.m. and 9 p.m. allowed me ample time to work). There, shivering in the ultra-cold air-conditioning which Malaysians and Singaporeans seem to favour, I found that the Malay language newspapers I wanted to read had been published solely in the Arabic script. On further digging, I could not find a single Malay newspaper which had not been printed in Jawi up to the Second World War. I was of course unable to read any of them; the Jawi which we had been taught in school was rudimentary, because Jawi was already not in everyday use by the time I went to school.

If Malay were still written today the way it used to be – in the Arabic script – would people go around denigrating it as a simple language?

I grew up hearing and speaking Malay every day but I took the language for granted, in the same way Malaysians assume they will see the sun every day. Only recently have I rediscovered Malay. At the same time, I began to appreciate the richness of Malaysia’s multilingual environment. I can easily recall the distinctive sounds of my native country: Malay, with its elegant smoothness; the no-frills brand of Cantonese I grew up with, rough and ready, a far cry from the haughty Hong Kong version but more in tune with the go-getting entrepreneurs who spoke it loudly and merrily; and the energetic, tongue-rolling Tamil used by our Indian friends, full of indecipherable syllables at which I could only shake my head.

We in Malaysia are fortunate to have this wealth as our heritage. But I have yet to hear a Malaysian adoring any of our languages the way the French adore theirs. The French are happy to debate the intricacies of their language for hours and will happily tell you how wonderful French is. This is something I wish Malaysians could also do, starting with our national language, Bahasa Malaysia. I would love to see Malaysians not only owning Bahasa Malaysia and learning it with enthusiasm, but also acknowledging its inherent poetry and being proud of it.



Filed under Cultural Identity, Malaysia, Novel, Research

11 responses to “An Unexpected Discovery

  1. Roslyn

    Well, appreciation of one’s heritage begins somewhere…and you’re that ‘somewhere’. Beautiful to hear in my mind those examples you give. I live in South Africa where we have 11 official languages – Xhosa, Zulu, Afrikaans, Sotho, Venda, Tswana, Ndebele, Northern Sotho, Swazi, Tsonga and English. Most people speak between 4 and 7 of these. Afrikaans is/was a lingua franca, developed in the early years of colonisation of the southern-most tip of the African continent. Given that slaves and indentured workers were brought from Malaya (and other British colonies) to work on the farms here, you won’t be surprised to hear there are many Malay words used commonly in South Africa now. For example piesang is the Malay and Afrikaans word for banana and South Africans and Malaysians both use blatjang as a cooking ingredient. So, Viva Bahasa Malaysia! I
    look forward to learning more.

  2. Fascinating post, Selina — I’ve got to share it with my sister!
    When we were younger, you see, my sister and I studied French. We used it as our (not-so) “secret language” when we wanted to talk about things without others (read as: parents) being able to understand. Then I fell in love in Mandarin, Cantonese and Japanese … and she began to study Spanish (and now Italian) … and we lost our ability to converse in a “secret” language. Ever since I was introduced to it while working at VOA, I’ve been trying to convince her that we should both study Bahasa Melayu.
    How do you say “Happy New Year and best of luck with your novel!” in Malay?

    • Hello there,

      I would encourage anyone who loves language (it sounds like you do) to study Bahasa. “Happy New Year and best of luck with your novel” would be, in formal Malay, Selamat Tahun Baru dan semoga berjaya dengan novel anda. Thank you! (Terima kasih)

  3. Grace Chin

    Yes! It is a very poetic language, and highly adaptable – literary Malay and formal standard Malay is so different from Melayu pasar or some kampung dialects, yet the language easily accommodates both. I suspect in time it will be as adaptable as English, if it survives that long! It borrows readily (elements of Dutch, Portuguese, English, Tagalog, and even Thai are discernible). I came to appreciate it from a BM teacher in secondary school who understood this socio-cultural background you’re referring to, and took pains to make us understand that language is culture, to show us the richness of that culture. One hopes that upcoming generations of Malaysians will appreciate their cultural heritage in its entirety. The process has already begun.

    • Hi Grace,

      Thank you for sharing your own experience. I’m looking forward to seeing the Malay language do more than survive, I’d like to see it thrive! It is after all a major language, counting 270 million speakers (according to Wikipedia).

      I’m also glad you believe future generations will appreciate our heritage in its entirety. I much hope you are right!

    • Sheema

      Actually, Malay does not borrow from Tagalog – they are both Austronesian languages with the same roots, and as such they simply have many words in common 🙂 But you are right about the other languages – to which we should also add Sanskrit, Arabic, Persian, and Hokkien of course 🙂

  4. Dominic

    A very interesting read thank you and HNY

  5. Sheema

    Thanks so much for writing this Chin Yoke! I consider Malay to be my mother tongue even though I first learnt to speak, read and write properly in English. I appreciate the sentiments you’ve expressed in your post as I love the language deeply, and lament its slow erosion. Sadly, due to various reasons I don’t get to use it as much or as well as I used to. And I only realised just how much everyday spoken Malay has lost its poetry when I talked to some Dayak people in Indonesian Borneo. They spoke in Bahasa Indonesia, which is of course mutually intelligible with Bahasa Malaysia. Yet the way they expressed themselves was so sweepingly poetic and evocative, using phrases, turns of language, metaphors and symbolism that they sounded positively Shakespearean even when talking about the most mundane topics. It made me sad that in Malaysia we have totally lost this kind of linguistic artistry.

    • Hello Sheema,

      Thank you for sharing your thoughts and your uplifting experience in Indonesian Borneo. I’ve never been there but your description has made me want to visit. All languages evolve and I hope Malay will too. It is up to us Malaysians to make sure it does!

What do You Think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s